Time for another review of a book that just came out today! First, a bit about me, however. You see, in the early 2000's I lived in a more metropolitan area of West Virginia, followed by a significantly rural area of Upstate New York. Living in these areas exposed me to folks who weren't just Christian, they were Christian. Their religion was a major part of their identity, and they wanted a culture that backed up their beliefs. They liked Christian music, television shows, movies, argued for, "Intelligent Design," and eagerly ignored any paradoxes or hypocrisies in their beliefs--if money is the root of all evil, why do many purveyors of Christian-influenced content get so rich and eagerly flaunt it? There is much to examine. Hence, "Jesusland: Stories from the Upside Down World of Christian Pop Culture," digs into all of that. This meaty book by Joelle Kidd contains nine assorted essays that examine everything from purity rings (you may recall those) to Christian lifestyle magazines for girls (you gotta dress modest to keep that boy you're into closer to Jesus than your genitals), to Kidd's own personal battles with her faith. She often grapples with how a religion that likes to act so persecuted also seems desperate to control much of the personal lives of others and force its way into popular culture in any manner it can. As I am someone who grew up somewhat parallel to those with fundamentalist/heavily conservative beliefs in the same time Kidd heavily examines (the early 2000's) I found, "Jesusland," intriguing as Hell, pun intended.
All of, "Jesusland," is a stellar read, with each chapter digging into varying aspects of Christianity and its weirdly siloed-off version of popular culture. There is one exact passage that really stuck with me in the book, however. It is on page 184 and it reads, "But no, as my teacher told it, if every word in the Bible was divinely inspired, then any one error would cause the entire thing to crumble. If scientists were able to prove that it wasn't true that the entire Earth was destroyed in a flood or that Jesus didn't really rise from the dead, then the whole of Christianity had lost its foundation. (Luckily, both these things were provable--we watched documentaries about them.) This is what really shook me to my core. What kind of faith was so tenous that had to be gripped so tightly?"
![]() |
Noah's Ark isn't a metaphor; it 100% happened. Right? |
That section sums up the, "All or nothing," view some Christians have perfectly. We have to avoid sex until marriage (and only heterosexual stuff), the Earth has to only be 6,000 years old, and every single word of the bible is meant to be taken literally as opposed to being a parable because if one single part of the bible isn't 100% true, it has to all be false, and our religion falls apart. Many folks can accept a bible is a product of interpretations, translations, and that there are various holy scriptures for many religions, but those Christians whose whole identity is being Christian as opposed to a part of their life? They can't roll with that. That said, what kind of faith is so tenous that is has to be gripped onto for dear life or else it crumbles into pieces? A flawed take on theology, I'd argue, and Kidd clearly agrees.
"Jesusland," is by no means anti-Christian. It is anti-extremist and provides an enligtening deep-dive into Christianity-focused culture. Scratch that, Christianity-obsessed culture is more accurate. When you're more worried about converting others to your faith than your own personal love for God (or love you get from God), you're doing religion wrong. When you blame victims for sexual assualt because they, "Tempted," a man with immodest dress, you're doing religion wrong. When you...you know what, I'm going to stop because this list could take hours. Within, "Jesusland," Kidd provides a superb mix of academic examination and personal anecdotes of those who took their Christianity to the extreme, and clearly were (and many still are) doing religion wrong.
![]() |
Still making movies (and loads of cash) in the name of Christ! |
We are now in 2025, and the book often points out how things have evolved or shifted from the earlier 2000s. Extremist Christian pop culture hasn't gone away. It has evolved (as ironic as that is to say) and changed itself in ways that ingratiate it with regular culture. Now it is about rebelling against things that are politically correct or woke, because Christians are the ones getting picked on...somehow. Maybe gay marriage isn't as much of a hot-button issue, but you can draw people slowly toward right-wing Christian Nationalism if you get them worried about transgender people playing sports. The little tweaks the far-right has made go on and on--right now diversity has become a dirty word with, "DEI," thrown around like a slur anytime someone who isn't a white male ascends to a position of power, as if being a minority somehow got them a job. "Jesusland," looks to the past, but is quite cognizant of how the successes and failures of extremist Christianity and its pop culture resulted in the ways it morphed itself for the present day.
"Jesusland: Stories from the Upside Down World of Christian Pop Culture," both evaluates a messy past and warns us about a dangerous future. The extremist aspects of Christianity have only gained more traction in the United States and even in parts of Canada. If people don't fight against hateful rhetoric or regressive thinking, both of those things will worm their way into society even more than is already quite apparent. The world of Christian Pop Culture is a twisted funhouse reflection of the real world. It is scary to think that a significant chunk of the population keeps pushing for that warped view of actuality to become accepted as fact and rule over our everyday lives. I appreciate Joelle Kidd writing this book to look back at a metaphorical yesterday and make us aware of the fight against a very upsetting possible tomorrow. Hell, it could literally be tomorrow in America, considering how fast things are going from bad to worse. I give, "Jesusland," a heavenly (pun intended, again)...
5 out of 5 Stars.
An advance copy was provided by ECW Press for the purposes of review.